No Free Lunch

Our health Care System is in Trouble


Between 1940 and 1960 spending on health care in the United States rose from 4% to 5.2% of the gross domestic product (GDP).

In the subsequent 35 years it has risen to over 15% of the GDP. Before the 1960's most medical care was paid for by individuals. Insurance was primarily for large expenses like hospitalization. There was an open market and prices were held down by competition. When the Medicare bill was passed during the Johnson administration several things happened which helped fuel the fire of health costs. Some of these things were beneficial for the general health of the American citizen but many were only beneficial to the pocket books of the medical and legal systems. Following are the major reasons that caused "managed care" to become the dominant force in American health care.

  1. Medicare policy, as defined by congress, paid hospitals and physicians whatever they asked for with no questions asked. Hospitals spent whatever they wanted to spend and simply passed the bill on to Medicare and the insurance companies. Back in that era most insurance coverage was for hospitalization only.
  2. Next, many individuals over the age of 65, who had used health care frugally prior to Medicare, began to see their physicians for more trivial problems. The change was helpful for the individuals who couldn't afford care prior to this time.
  3. The insurance companies initiated the policy of paying the hospitals the same as Medicare reimbursement which, if you remember from above, was whatever the hospitals asked for. It didn't matter to insurance companies at that time, though, because they had no reason to hold back costs. It was easier to adjust premiums. They made money by setting premiums at a level that guaranteed that the system was profitable.
  4. Eventually, as people saw doctors and hospitals making windfall profits, the legal profession and individuals who might have some complaint against the medical system began cashing in on the profits through lawsuits
  5. Although there are numerous other reasons for the exorbitant escalation in medical care costs over the past 30 years the final major reason is the advance in technology. Government and insurance company policy of paying for this technology, without question, was the driving force in the quick advance of the technology. That policy has led to a medical system that is second to none but at a price that is astronomically higher than any other on earth. We have been subsidizing the rest of the world in technological and pharmaceutical advances. We pay for it, as individuals, through higher drug and health care costs in addition to higher taxes.

Current Status

The current state of American Health Care is overwhelmingly driven by cost.

Our Employers are faced with the overwhelming cost of Providing Medical Care for their Employees. We as Employees are faced with the surprise that our "so called insurance" will not pay for chemically induced illness or injury.

Doctors struggle to diagnose an illness that they are not trained to recognize but are trained (under the Cullen Definition) to prove that your illness was caused by something other than chemicals. The cost of Medical care and Workers compensation is being shifted to Social Security Disability and Medicare.

It's about time that we as chemically injured, get "Appropriate Medical Care" by Qualified Physicians. Doctors that consume Thousands of Dollars of our Insurance money with the intention of trying to avoid a Chemically Induced Injury diagnosis should be sued for Negligent or Mal Practice. If our Insurance cost is to high because of the "so called experts" playing games with our health, we may even loose our jobs --- then our Medical Care (Insurance).

How about a new rule for the "Experts". No Diagnosis - No Pay.

Managed Care is the new catch phrase. It is being touted as the savior of the health care system. But, Managed Care is being quickly recognized for what it is. Saving money at the expense of people's lives and health is unconscionable. The reality is turning out to be that, although there is some money being saved, there is more cost shifting than cost saving.

We, as a patient, have the undesirable option of either changing doctors every time the insurance changes or paying expenses out of our own pocket. But remember, "There Is No Free Lunch". We will pay much of the cost of Medical Care.

Back to NC Chemical Injury Network